What Your 2026 Cyber Renewal Application Is Really Asking About MFA
In 2022, ransomware hit International Control Services, an Illinois electronics manufacturer. According to Reed Smith, its insurer, Travelers, denied the claim and then sued in federal court to cancel the company’s $1 million cyber policy.
Travelers alleged that the application required MFA for email, remote access, servers, and other systems. According to the filing, the company used MFA only on its firewall, and the servers the attackers hit had none. As Dark Reading reported, both sides agreed to void the policy a few weeks later.
No judge ruled on whether those allegations were true. Still, the case shows how insurers treat an application after a claim: they compare each answer to what the company had in place on the day of the attack.
A voided policy can hurt more than a denial
A denial rejects one claim and leaves the rest of the policy in place. A voided policy cancels the whole contract as if it never existed.
Travelers asked the court to declare that it owed ICS nothing for any claim under the policy. The company learned this after the attack, too late to close the gap. For a policyholder, a voided policy is never better than a denial and is often much worse.
How most applications get answered
The renewal application usually goes from finance to IT or the MSP, and it comes back a day later with every box checked. Few people ask where MFA is turned on, even though underwriters review that detail at renewal and claims teams test it after an attack.
Mid-market companies carry the most risk
According to Verizon’s 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report, ransomware appeared in 48% of breaches. The report covers incidents from November 2024 through October 2025.
Coveware’s Q2 2026 report shows who gets hit. Companies with 11 to 10,000 employees accounted for 75.8% of ransomware cases, and the median victim had 750 employees. If your company falls in that range, it fits the typical victim profile.
Coveware also found that attackers often get in through normal login paths. They talk help desks into resetting MFA, use remote access portals, and sign in with stolen passwords, so the attack looks like a regular employee or vendor logging in.
AI makes these gaps easier to find
According to Verizon, attackers now use generative AI to work faster at every stage of an attack, from spotting security gaps to writing malware.
That raises the stakes for MFA. AI helps attackers write more convincing phishing messages, sound more believable on a help desk call, and scan for remote sign-in pages that lack MFA. A partial MFA rollout that once went unnoticed is now much more likely to get found.
Where a “yes” often falls short
Three gaps show up repeatedly:
- Partial coverage. MFA protects email, but remote access, servers, admin accounts, or the backup console go without it.
- Weak reset process. The help desk resets MFA for anyone who sounds convincing on the phone.
- Vendor access. Vendors and MSPs sign in to your systems without MFA.
A fintech company with about $250 million in annual sales came to C3 for its renewal. Its IT team had marked MFA as “yes” across the board. When we reviewed the answers together, we found that MFA protected email but not remote sign-in, so anyone with a stolen password could reach the company’s network from outside the office. The company enabled MFA for remote sign-in and updated its application before submitting anything.
What a solid answer looks like
Start with a report that shows, system by system, where MFA is required, and answer the application using that report rather than from memory.
According to Coveware, companies should use phishing-resistant MFA for privileged accounts, remote access, SaaS and cloud platforms, and backup admin accounts. Use that list as your checklist.
Then document how your help desk verifies a person’s identity before changing any MFA setting. Require vendors and MSPs to use named accounts with MFA, log their access, and remove it when the work ends.
Three questions to ask before you sign
- Where does MFA protect us, and where does it not?
- How does our help desk confirm someone’s identity before it resets MFA?
- Does every vendor and MSP with access to our systems use MFA?
If an answer doesn’t match your application, fix the gap or correct the application before you submit it. Have a licensed professional review any wording questions, since your answers become part of the underwriting file.
MFA is the best place to start because it is often the easiest gap to identify and the cheapest to close
The time to fix an MFA gap is before the application goes out, while it is still a quick fix rather than a coverage problem.
We review cyber applications against what is in place, so the answers hold up at if you have a claim.
To talk through your MFA answers or any other part of your cyber application, visit c3insurance.com/cyber or email our Cyber Group Practice Leader, Joe Erle, at joe@c3insurance.com.


